Aurora, Colorado – A case that has drawn national attention for its implications on law enforcement’s use of force took a significant turn as Randy Roedema and Jason Rosenblatt, two former Aurora police officers, pleaded not guilty to charges of reckless manslaughter and assault in connection with the death of Elijah McClain. The court proceedings have been closely followed as it took an unexpected twist when the jury recessed Wednesday evening without reaching a verdict after deliberating for eight hours. Deliberations began the day prior and will resume the following day at 8:30 a.m. local time.
Throughout the day, the jury raised several questions, three of which were related to the two officers’ field experience. The court assured jurors that they had already received all the evidence and testimony necessary to make a decision in the case.
The trial, which spanned several weeks, featured intense closing arguments that highlighted the stark differences in perspectives between the prosecution and the defense. Prosecutors contended that Roedema and Rosenblatt employed excessive force, failed to adhere to their training, and misled paramedics about Elijah McClain’s health status. Prosecutor Duane Lyons passionately argued that the officers were trained and given instructions to de-escalate the situation and listen to McClain. He accused them of failing in their duty.
In contrast, defense attorneys sought to shift blame onto the paramedics and McClain himself. Jason Rosenblatt’s attorney, Harvey Steinberg, portrayed his client as a “scapegoat” and asserted that it was the paramedics’ responsibility to evaluate a patient’s medical condition. Roedema’s attorney, Don Sisson, argued that his client’s use of force was justified because McClain resisted arrest, noting that McClain had been given 34 commands to either “stop” or “stop fighting.”
The case centers on the events of August 24, 2019, when officers responded to a call about a “suspicious person” wearing a ski mask. They confronted McClain, a young man who worked as a massage therapist and was known as a musician and animal lover, as he was walking home from a convenience store with a plastic bag containing iced tea. Body camera footage showed the officers wrestling McClain to the ground and applying a carotid hold, while paramedics subsequently administered a powerful sedative, ketamine. McClain later suffered a heart attack on the way to the hospital and was declared dead three days later.
Prosecutors initially declined to bring charges against the officers, but renewed scrutiny of the case following the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests led to a special prosecutor’s appointment by Colorado Governor Jared Polis, culminating in a grand jury indicting three officers and two paramedics in McClain’s death.
A third officer, Nathan Woodyard, and two paramedics, Jeremy Cooper and Peter Cichuniec, are set to go on trial in the coming weeks and have also pleaded not guilty.
The key focal point of the trial was the circumstance of McClain’ death and whether the officers’ actions played a role. A pulmonary critical care physician testified that McClain may not have died had paramedics recognized his medical issues and intervened accordingly. Dr. Robert Mitchell Jr., a forensic pathologist who reviewed McClain’s autopsy, stated that there was a “direct causal link” between the officers’ actions and McClain’s death.
In contrast, the defense argued that there was no evidence that the officers’ actions led to McClain’s death and pointed to the ketamine injection as a potential cause.
The trial raised questions about the cause of McClain’s death. While an initial autopsy report labeled the cause of death as undetermined, an amended report released in 2022 listed “complications of ketamine administration following forcible restraint” as the cause of death. The manner of death remained undetermined. Dr. Stephen Cina, the pathologist who signed the autopsy report, noted that he saw no evidence of injuries inflicted by police that contributed to McClain’s death and suggested that McClain would likely be alive if not for the ketamine administration.
In the prosecution’s rebuttal, Jason Slothouber argued that the officers’ failure to protect McClain’s airway allowed him to become hypoxic and acidotic, rendering the ketamine administration dangerous. Slothouber emphasized that officers provided inaccurate information to the paramedics, ultimately failing Elijah McClain.
As the case unfolds, it remains a focal point in the ongoing discussion of police conduct, use of force, and accountability within the American criminal justice system. The nation watches on as the trial sets a precedent for similar cases in the future.
Written by Ava LeFevre
